All ___ are not ___: a common statement that’s nearly always wrong
Am I the only person annoyed with this linguistic atrocity? Do a Google search some time on “all ___ are not”, filling in the blank with any common plural noun. Or search “all ____ is not,” filling in the blank with a collective noun. You’ll find statements like All women are not a size 2. All teenagers are not brats. All paper is not 8 1/2 x 11. All coffee is not espresso. These sentences make a statement in the negative about all women, teenagers, paper, or coffee. And they are all false statements. Some women are a size 2. Some teenagers are brats. Lots of paper (in this country, anyway) isĀ 8 1/2 x 11. Some coffee is espresso. Here is what the writers probably meant: Not all women are a size 2. Not all teenagers are brats. Not all paper is 8 1/2 x 11. Not all coffee is espresso. Instead of creating an overly broad generalization, this construction negates one. These statements are correct. It’s harder to argue with a statement like “all women are not the same,” partly because it’s so vague that the answer “but some women are the same” does not obviously falsify it. … Continue reading →